NEWS & ARTICLES
Permanent Court of Arbitration rules India's IWT suspension illegal as India rejects the verdict and dismisses the court itself
ALLNEWS
The Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague has ruled that India's suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty is illegal under international law, finding that no rule of international law allows a state to unilaterally suspend a treaty on the grounds of sovereign right, and rejecting every argument India offered to justify placing the six-decade-old water-sharing agreement in abeyance since April 2025. The court further concluded that even if India's allegations regarding cross-border terrorism were assumed to be true, they would not establish a material breach of the IWT, and that the existence of armed conflict could not provide basis for suspension, noting the treaty had remained operational through multiple wars since 1960.
India's response was to reject both the ruling and the court itself, with the Ministry of External Affairs declaring the court was constituted in patent breach of the treaty and that India never recognised it, never appeared before it, and will not be bound by its pronouncements
Kashmir Conflict states what this position reveals. India accepted previous rulings from international arbitration mechanisms when those rulings served its interests. It now declares the same court illegal when the ruling goes against it. That is not a principled position on jurisdiction. It is selective compliance dressed in sovereignty language.
The Indus river system is the primary water source for hundreds of millions of people across Pakistan. The court has also restricted India's construction at its Ratle hydroelectric plant in Kashmir pending a neutral expert's decision expected in July 2027. India states it will continue regardless. The withholding of water from an entire downstream population through the unilateral suspension of a binding international treaty, in defiance of a court ruling declaring it illegal, is not a sovereign decision. It is an act of aggression that legal scholars and water rights advocates state can constitute a war crime under international humanitarian law. India opened the Salal Dam gates in August. It is now flouting the court order that confirmed its actions are illegal. The water flows on India's terms. The ruling changes nothing it has decided to do.
Follow Our Social Media
KASHMIR CONFLICT | LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM (UK) | © 2026 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED